Here’s some light reading: the U.S. Dept. of Veterans Affairs’ Office of the Inspector General’s “Audit of the Project Management Accountability System Implementation.” Known as “PMAS,” the system was put in place in 2009 to provide better oversight of the VA’s troubled IT development projects. This was done in light of a history of cost overruns and failed IT projects at the VA.
Having been a VA consultant (in the area of social media), and having done a detailed review on my own of the PMAS’ initial guidebook issued by the VA’s CIO, I have some familiarity with the environment and the implementation challenges PMAS faced.
What’s the moral of this story? Evidently, providing serious oversight of multimillion dollar programs requires much more time, attention, and resources than the VA was able — or willing — to devote to the problem. Also, we can’t tell what, if any, were the political forces that also played a role in undermining the PMAS effort.
For example, were staff and managers of individual projects always completely forthcoming and cooperative in providing input data to the PMAS staff? There are incidents described in the report, for example, where troubled — and ultimately cancelled — projects were consistently shown to be in the “green” despite repeated problems.
Also, was it appropriate to create a “dashboard” process which, by definition, assumes availability of appropriate and timely data? Or would it have been more appropriate and effective to start out with less formalized and more personal reporting processes that would take advantage of modern telecommunication and conferencing so that program and project managers could interact spontaneously in real time? Such processes are time consuming and weigh heavily on senior management, but perhaps they should be attempted at least as an interim process. Even more significantly, were managers of targeted projects collaboratively involved in developing the PMAS approach? Had they been, would they have raised issues concerning the level of effort involved in implementing and operating PMAS?
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.