When You Don’t Feel Like the Leader You Already Are 

There’s a particular kind of quiet that shows up after a promotion, a reorg or a new title; a competence that looks real from the outside and doesn’t feel real from the inside. You’re doing the job. You’re doing it well, by most honest measures. And somewhere underneath that, a steady, low hum of they’re going to figure out I don’t actually know what I’m doing. 

This is often called imposter syndrome, and it tends to get talked about as a personality quirk something certain people are simply more prone to, and something they need to individually will their way past. I don’t think that’s quite right, and I don’t think it’s especially kind to the people carrying it. What I’ve come to believe, watching this pattern up close, is that it isn’t a character flaw. It’s closer to a loop that’s gotten stuck, and stuck loops can be understood, and gently worked with, in a way that pure willpower never quite manages. 

The Shape of the Loop

It tends to run something like this: Underneath the feeling sits a belief, often something like people who really belong here don’t have to work this hard or if I actually knew what I was doing, I wouldn’t feel this uncertain. That belief quietly shapes how everything gets read afterward. A win gets filed away as luck, timing or a low bar. A hard day gets filed away as proof. Useful feedback lands as a threat rather than information. And because that interpretation feels true, the response follows it — over-preparing, over-explaining, holding back from the harder assignments, checking in more than is really needed just to be sure. 

Here’s the part that makes the loop so sticky: The exhaustion that comes from all that overcompensating gets read as more evidence for the original belief. Look how much effort this is taking me, a real expert wouldn’t need to work this hard. And so the belief gets a little more solid, and the cycle runs again. 

None of this is a sign that someone is unusually fragile or poorly suited to leadership. It’s closer to a wiring pattern that most competent, conscientious people run into somewhere along the way, often loudest at exactly the moments when they’ve just stepped into more responsibility than they’ve held before. 

Why Reassurance Alone Doesn’t Hold 

The instinct, when someone we care about is caught in this, is to tell them the truth: You’re doing a great job; you clearly know what you’re doing. That’s not wrong to say, and it’s not without value. But it tends not to hold, because it’s addressing the feeling without addressing the loop underneath it. The belief is still sitting there, quietly reinterpreting the next win as luck and the next hard day as proof, no matter how many kind things get said in between. 

What seems to actually shift something is working on a few different levels at once, rather than expecting one conversation or one pep talk to do all the work. 

Catching It While It’s Happening

The first level is simply learning to notice the pattern in real time, recognizing this is the loop talking, not the truth when a success gets waved away or a hard moment gets treated as confirmation. This sounds small, almost too small to matter, but noticing a thought as a thought, rather than as a fact, is often the first crack in a belief that’s felt solid for a long time. 

Keeping the Evidence Somewhere

The second level is building an actual record, something concrete to hold up against the loop’s version of events. For a leader, this might be as simple as keeping a running note of decisions made under pressure, problems that got solved, moments a team member said something landed well. Not to perform confidence, but because the loop has a way of quietly editing memory, and a plain, ongoing record is hard to argue with in the way a feeling isn’t. 

Not Carrying It Alone 

The third level, and maybe the one that matters most, is letting other people reflect it back. The loop tends to run in isolation; it’s much harder to sustain a belief that you don’t belong when someone who respects your work says, plainly and specifically, here’s what I saw you do well, and here’s why it mattered. This isn’t the same as vague encouragement. It’s specific, and it’s said out loud, and it’s said more than once. 

A Learnable Pattern, Not a Fixed Trait

None of this makes the feeling disappear overnight, and it probably shouldn’t, a little humility about how much there still is to learn is honest, and worth keeping. But there’s a real difference between productive humility and the quieter, heavier belief that you don’t actually belong in the room. The first one keeps a leader curious and grounded. The second one just wears a person down. 

Leaders stepping into more than they’ve held before are especially likely to meet this loop, simply because the gap between what the role asks and what feels fully mastered is often at its widest right at the start. That gap isn’t proof of anything except that the role is new. What closes it, over time, isn’t forcing a feeling of confidence to appear; it’s rebuilding the mechanisms that let real competence actually register: noticing the pattern, keeping the evidence and letting it be witnessed rather than carried alone. 

Megan Rodgers is a doctoral candidate and human services professional with over eight years of experience coordinating multidisciplinary teams across complex organizational systems. Her work sits at the intersection of clinical practice and applied theory, with a particular focus on systems thinking, self-control frameworks, and the institutional forces that shape human behavior. Megan has presented at professional conferences on topics including imposter syndrome, bringing research-grounded insight to audiences navigating the realities of public service. She is passionate about bridging the gap between academic theory and everyday practice; making big ideas accessible, actionable, and real.

Photo Credit: